Choosing the right printer can feel overwhelming. Inkjet and laser printers are the two main types available, each with unique strengths and weaknesses. Understanding the differences between Inkjet Vs Laser Printer is key to making an informed decision for your home or office needs.
This comprehensive guide breaks down everything you need to know to confidently choose between an inkjet or laser printer. We’ll explore crucial factors like print quality, speed, cost, and usage scenarios to help you determine the best printer type for your specific requirements.
Printer Comparison: Inkjet vs Laser
To make the choice easier, let’s dive into a detailed inkjet vs laser printer comparison.
What is an Inkjet Printer?
Inkjet printers are a popular choice for home users due to their affordability and versatility. They work by spraying tiny droplets of ink onto paper to create text and images. Inkjet printers excel at producing high-quality color prints, particularly photographs, and are generally more compact and less expensive upfront than laser printers. However, the cost of ink cartridges and slower print speeds are factors to consider.
What is a Laser Printer?
Laser printers utilize toner powder instead of liquid ink. A laser beam and drum unit are used to fuse toner onto paper, resulting in sharp, crisp text and fast print speeds. While laser printers may have a higher initial cost, they often prove more economical in the long run for high-volume printing due to their lower cost per page and efficient toner usage. Laser printers are widely used in offices and are increasingly becoming a cost-effective option for home use as well.
Let’s examine the key differences in more detail to help you decide:
Intended Use: What Will You Be Printing?
Consider what you’ll primarily be printing to guide your printer choice.
For occasional home printing, inkjet printers are often suggested due to their lower initial cost. However, a common issue with inkjet printers is ink drying out when not used frequently. If budget allows, an entry-level laser printer is a strong alternative as toner doesn’t dry out.
If you need to print high-resolution color images and photos regularly in smaller volumes, inkjet printers are well-suited. For frequent, large volume printing of both monochrome and color documents, laser printers are more robust and efficient.
Monochrome Printer Explained: A monochrome printer prints only in black and white, using only a black cartridge.
While laser printers were initially designed for office environments, their economic advantages are making them increasingly popular as home printers.
For high-volume printing, laser printers are the clear winner. They are built to handle substantial daily print loads without performance issues.
Color Printing Considerations: Color laser printers are suitable for everyday color documents. However, for professional, gallery-quality photos, a dedicated photo inkjet printer is recommended. These specialized inkjet printers use pigment-based inks for superior color depth, detail, and longevity, and support various paper types and sizes preferred by photographers and artists. Dye-based inks are also available for inkjet photo printers if archival quality is less critical.
Inkjet vs. Color Laser for Color Printing: A frequent question is whether to choose a color laser or inkjet printer for color prints.
- For professional-grade photo printing, a photo inkjet printer is essential.
- For general color documents and images where extreme color accuracy isn’t paramount, color laser printers are often a better long-term choice due to toner longevity and lower long-term costs. Laser toner doesn’t dry out, and toner cartridges yield significantly more pages than inkjet cartridges.
Printing Technology: How Inkjet and Laser Printers Work
Inkjet printers use a straightforward process of spraying liquid ink onto paper through microscopic nozzles.
Inkjet Printing Technology
Laser printers employ a more complex mechanism. They use a drum unit to precisely melt toner powder onto paper using heat.
Laser Printing Technology
Essentially, inkjet printers use ink, and laser printers use powder. This difference leads to the common perception that inkjet prints are more prone to smudging. While this can be true for some inkjet printers using dye-based inks (which require longer drying times), pigment-based inkjet inks are much less likely to smudge. The type of paper also plays a significant role in ink absorption and smudge resistance for both inkjet and laser prints.
Print Quality and Resolution
Print quality, technically known as print resolution, depends on your specific printing needs.
For exceptionally detailed, high-resolution photos, a professional photo inkjet printer designed for high DPI (dots per inch) output is the best choice. For sharp text documents and satisfactory color graphics, laser printers are highly capable and reliable.
Color Laser Print Quality: While inkjet printers still lead in ultimate photo quality with superior color depth and subtlety, advancements in laser technology have significantly improved color laser printer output. Modern color laser printers can produce impressive color photos suitable for many general-purpose color printing tasks.
Print Resolution Comparison (DPI): Resolution is measured in DPI. Higher DPI means more dots per inch, resulting in sharper images. A resolution of 600 DPI is sufficient for high-quality documents, and 1200 DPI is adequate for good color images. Beyond 1200 DPI, the visual difference is often negligible, except for specialized photo printing.
Printer specifications list resolution as two numbers (e.g., 4800 x 1200 DPI), representing the maximum horizontal and vertical DPI. Excessively high DPI is generally unnecessary for most users.
Inkjet Printer Resolutions: Inkjet printers typically offer maximum resolutions around 5000 DPI. Canon PIXMA printers often reach 4800 x 1200 DPI, while Epson photo printers can achieve up to 5760 x 1440 DPI. Some models, like the Canon iP110, boast even higher resolutions like 9600 x 2400 DPI.
Laser Printer Resolutions: Laser printers commonly have resolutions up to 2400 x 600 DPI. Newer models, such as the HP Color LaserJet Pro M479fdw, can use DPI optimization for enhanced resolutions up to 38,400 x 600 DPI.
Summary of Print Quality by Printer Type:
- Monochrome Laser: Excellent for crisp text and documents.
- Color Laser: Excellent for text, documents, and good-quality color graphics (suitable for general use color images).
- Photo Inkjet: Best for professional, high-resolution photos with extensive color range and tonal depth, ideal for gallery-quality prints.
Print Speed
Laser printers are designed for office productivity, prioritizing speed. They print significantly faster than inkjet printers, ranging from 15 to 100 pages per minute (PPM), while inkjet printers average around 16 PPM. This speed advantage allows laser printers to handle larger print volumes and results in a higher monthly duty cycle.
- Laser Printers: 15-100 PPM
- Inkjet Printers: ~16 PPM
Print Volume
Print volume indicates a printer’s capacity for handling large print jobs. Laser printers are considered office workhorses due to their ability to quickly process and print large quantities of documents. Inkjet printers, primarily designed for home use, have a much lower print volume capacity.
Consider this comparison between the HP LaserJet Pro M401n (laser) and the Canon PIXMA TR8620 (inkjet):
| Feature | HP LaserJet Pro M401n (Laser) | Canon PIXMA TR8620 (Inkjet) |
|---|---|---|
| Print Speed | 35 PPM | 15 PPM |
| Monthly Print Volume | 750-3,000 pages | Less than 1,000 pages |
The difference in print speed and monthly print volume is substantial.
Understanding Monthly Duty Cycle and Recommended Print Volume: It’s important to distinguish between these two specifications:
- Maximum Monthly Duty Cycle: The maximum number of pages a printer can theoretically print in a month without component damage.
- Recommended Monthly Print Volume: The ideal number of pages to print monthly to maintain optimal printer performance and longevity.
Exceeding the recommended monthly print volume, even if within the maximum duty cycle, can shorten the printer’s lifespan. It’s best to stay within the recommended print volume for long-term reliability.
Page Yield and Cartridge Longevity
Toner cartridges in laser printers offer significantly higher page yields compared to inkjet cartridges. Toner cartridges can typically print from 2,000 up to 10,000 pages or more, while standard inkjet cartridges often yield only 135 to 1,000 pages. This means toner cartridges last much longer, reducing replacement frequency.
Ink Tank Printers: Ink tank printers have emerged as an inkjet alternative to address cartridge replacement frequency. Brands like Epson, Canon, and HP offer ink tank models that use refillable ink bottles instead of cartridges, drastically increasing ink capacity. For example, an Epson 522 cyan ink bottle can print approximately 7,000 pages. Brother’s ink tank printers use larger cartridges with increased ink volume, with some reaching up to 6,000 pages per cartridge.
Important Note on Ink Tank Printers: While ink tank printers offer higher ink volumes, they are still inkjet printers and are still susceptible to ink drying and nozzle clogs if not used regularly.
Ink tank printers are suitable for users who print color documents frequently and in larger volumes. However, for infrequent printing, a color laser printer may be a better choice to avoid ink drying issues.
Printer and Cartridge Costs
The initial purchase price of an inkjet printer is generally lower than a laser printer. Entry-level inkjet models can be very affordable, while laser printers typically start at a higher price point.
Beware of Very Cheap Inkjet Printers: Extremely inexpensive inkjet printers often have a high cost per page due to low-yield ink cartridges that require frequent replacement. The long-term ink costs can quickly exceed the printer’s initial price.
Inkjet printers tend to have a shorter lifespan (around 3 years) compared to laser printers (5 years or more), which also contributes to the pricing difference. Longevity depends on usage frequency for both types.
Cartridge Costs and Cost Per Page are Key: When evaluating printer costs, focus on cartridge prices and, more importantly, the cost per page (CPP).
Laser printer toner cartridges are typically more expensive upfront than inkjet cartridges, but they yield significantly more pages. This translates to a lower CPP, making laser printers more economical for higher volume printing.
Calculating Cost Per Page: CPP is the most effective way to compare printer efficiency. Calculate CPP by dividing the cartridge price by its page yield:
Cost Per Page = Cartridge Price / Cartridge Page Yield
Using the HP LaserJet M401n and Canon TR8620 examples again:
| Feature | HP LaserJet Pro M401n (Laser) | Canon PIXMA TR8620 (Inkjet) |
|---|---|---|
| Cartridge | HP 80X Black Toner | Canon PGI-280XL Black Ink |
| Page Yield | 6,900 pages | 400 pages |
| Cartridge Cost | ~$216.89 (as of 8/22/2023) | ~$27.99 (as of 8/22/2023) |
| Cost Per Page | ~3.1 cents | ~6.9 cents |
Despite the higher toner cartridge price, the HP 80X laser toner has a significantly lower CPP (3.1 cents) compared to the Canon PGI-280XL ink cartridge (6.9 cents).
Consider Compatible Cartridges: To reduce toner costs, explore compatible toner cartridge options.
Compatible, non-OEM ink and toner cartridges are widely available at significantly lower prices and can offer comparable print quality to brand-name cartridges.
Comparing original vs. compatible HP 80X toner:
- Original HP 80X Toner: ~$216.89
- Compatible HP 80X Toner: ~$29.99
Compatible cartridges can offer substantial savings, in this case, around 84% less than the original. Similar savings are often available for compatible inkjet cartridges.
[banner image]
While inkjet printers may seem cheaper initially, the ongoing cost of ink cartridges, especially with frequent replacements due to lower page yields, can make them more expensive in the long run. Laser printers, with their higher page yields and lower CPP, often become more cost-effective over time, especially for regular printing.
Drum Unit Considerations in Laser Printers
Another difference is that inkjet printers only require ink cartridges, while laser printers need both toner cartridges and a drum unit. The drum unit in a laser printer transfers toner to the paper. In some laser printers, the toner and drum are integrated into a single unit (like in some HP models). In others, like Brother laser printers, they are separate.
When buying a laser printer, check if the toner and drum are separate and if you’ll need to replace both. Drum units have a longer lifespan than toner cartridges and typically need replacement less frequently (every 3-4 toner cartridge replacements). Learn more about the difference between toner and drum units. Don’t be discouraged by the drum unit; its infrequent replacement doesn’t negate the overall cost benefits of laser printers, especially for regular printing.
Ink Cartridge Alternatives
Printer manufacturers offer alternatives to standard ink cartridges to address the inconvenience and cost of frequent replacements.
HP Instant Ink Subscription
HP’s Instant Ink program is a subscription service that automatically sends ink cartridges when your printer detects low ink levels. While convenient, reviews of the service are mixed. Research HP Instant Ink reviews before subscribing to understand potential drawbacks.
Ink Tank Printers (Continuous Ink Supply System – CISS)
Epson, Brother, Canon, and HP offer ink tank printers that use large, refillable ink tanks instead of cartridges. These printers use a Continuous Ink Supply System (CISS).
Learn more about ink tank printers, their advantages over standard inkjet printers, and comparisons to laser printers.
Drawbacks of ink tank printers include:
- Higher initial cost than standard inkjet printers.
- Ink can still clog nozzles and printheads if the printer is not used regularly.
Consider your printing frequency before investing in a more expensive ink tank printer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is a good home printer for both black and color documents, suitable for home and school use, that won’t dry out?
A: A color laser printer meets these requirements. They print both black and color, use toner (no drying issues), and don’t have printheads prone to clogging. HP Color LaserJet and Canon Color ImageClass printers are known for good color print quality. Choose home or small business models, and read customer reviews for specific model comparisons.
Q: I print regularly and need a cost-efficient color printer. Inkjet or laser?
A: Consider either a good color laser printer (HP or Canon) or an ink tank printer. Laser toner cartridges and ink tank printers offer high page yields, making them more cost-effective for regular, high-volume printing compared to standard inkjet printers.
Q: I need to print high-resolution photos for my home business. Can a color laser printer work?
A: For professional-quality, high-resolution photos, a dedicated photo inkjet printer is still recommended. Color laser printers, while improved, cannot match the color accuracy and detail of top photo inkjet printers due to limitations in laser printing technology.
Q: Can laser printers print stickers or labels?
A: Yes, laser printers can print stickers and labels using laser-compatible sticker paper. Crucially, do not use inkjet sticker paper in a laser printer as it can melt and severely damage the printer’s fuser unit. For vibrant, high-quality color stickers, inkjet printers are often preferred. Inkjet printers also offer options for water-resistant and fade-proof labels, especially when using pigment-based inks.
Inkjet vs Laser Printer: Key Differences Summarized
[summary image]
Inkjet Printers
Pros:
- Compact and lightweight.
- Excellent photo and image print quality.
- Lower initial cost.
- No warm-up time.
- Versatile paper compatibility (glossy photo paper, art paper, fabrics).
- Larger paper size handling.
- Ink refill kits available for cost reduction.
Cons:
- Ink cartridges are expensive and have low page yields, leading to higher running costs for frequent printing.
- Slower print speeds.
- Smaller paper trays (50-100 sheets).
- Lower monthly duty cycle.
- Ink can smudge and dries slower.
- Ink can dry out if not used regularly.
Laser Printers
Pros:
- Faster print speeds.
- Sharp, crisp text output.
- High monthly duty cycle for large print jobs.
- Lower long-term cost per page for frequent printing.
- Toner is more stable than ink and doesn’t dry out.
Cons:
- Challenged with complex graphics and photo printing.
- Generally larger and heavier than inkjet printers.
- Limited paper type compatibility compared to inkjet.
- Higher initial cost.
Conclusion:
The best choice between inkjet vs laser printer depends on your printing needs, volume, and budget. Inkjet printers are suitable for home users who primarily print photos and occasional color documents in smaller volumes. Laser printers are more efficient and economical for users who print frequently, especially text-heavy documents and larger volumes.
Consider your future printing needs as well. Will your printing demands increase? Choosing a printer that aligns with your long-term needs can save you money and hassle in the future.
For printer recommendations, explore our guides to the best laser printers and best inkjet printers. Happy printer shopping!
| Cartridge Series |
|---|
| Thank you for reading! This article is by the ink experts at LD Products, a Long Beach, California-based company specializing in compatible ink and toner. With over 20 years of printing expertise, we help you save money on printer ink without sacrificing quality. Visit LDProducts.com for all your ink and toner needs. Your support is appreciated! |
